Bailout money for the rich;
nothing for the hungry poor
Albay Governor Joey Salceda, an economic adviser to President Arroyo, laments that the world’s richest countries, notably the United States and England, are spending a total of $6.8 trillion to bail out banks and investment houses made bankrupt by the financial crisis sweeping through America and Europe.
Yet, when food prices doubled early this year bringing to the precipice of hunger up to 130 million very poor, all these rich countries could scrounge was $850 million to bail these people out of hunger.
“The elite controls governments and in a crisis, they save their ilk first,” sneers Salceda who made his pile as one of Asia’s leading analysts. With the multi-trillion bailouts, the rich countries will be piling up huge debts chargeable to their taxpayers. Salceda frets that “funds for social services and international development will be displaced, causing income inequality to deteriorate.”
How true.
***
That the small people will be the biggest victims of the financial crash in America is amply demonstrated by the way Philamlife is treating its plan holders in the Philippines. Philamlife is the subsidiary of global insurance giant AIG which went bankrupt on Sept. 15 and had to be bailed out by the US government with $85 billion in expensive rescue fund plus another $37 billion later.
A harried mother of three went to Philamlife offices on DasmariƱas, Cavite to inquire if she can cash in her Brilliance University educational insurance. She was told she wouldn’t get anything. Zero. Zilch. For her P87,000 initial payment, she will get a cash surrender value of P1,055 -- but only in the second year.
By any measure, this seems to me like a big swindle. Even banks, if you place a time deposit and want to get out, you pay a termination fee of just 20 percent. With Philam, the pretermination fee is 100 percent. You lose all your money. They take away your money. Just like that. Cannot the Insurance Commission or the SEC do something about this?
What grates the poor housewife is that the people at Philamlife sounded and acted even cold, impersonal, haughty and arrogant. Something like, “if you want your money back, maghintay ka, bruha!”
Wow! And to think that Philamlife is for all practical purposes bankrupt. Its mother company, AIG, owes the US government at least $122 billion, money it cannot possibly raise considering the debts it has piled up, about $450 billion in credit default swaps (CDS) much of it can no longer be converted into cash. To raise money, AIG has to sell its assets including Philamlife.
The sale clearly obscures the outlook of Philamlife. What are the chances of the new owners of Philamlife honoring Philamlife’s obligations?
***
Sen. Chiz Escudero has filed a bill increasing the insurance cover of deposits to P500,000 from the present P250,000. The measure also mandates the Philippine Deposit Insurance Corp. (PDIC) to tighten supervision over banks, check abuses of bank owners and executives as regards pay and bonuses, and ensure regular, prompt and transparent disclosure of financial condition.
The bill affirms the power of the PDIC to invest in banks. This is the Philippine equivalent of a contingent bailout if the financial crisis abroad worsens and starts sweeping through Manila.
In the meantime, our banks and financial houses seem to be on a sound financial footing. Banking, however, is a confidence game. Once a bank loses the confidence of its clients and depositors, the institution, no matter how old, venerable and seemingly stable, can be toppled overnight.
Also, clients, depositors and investors remember who treated them well in good times. And bad.
biznewsasia@gmail.com
Monday, October 20, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
You said, "A harried mother of three went to Philamlife offices on DasmariƱas, Cavite to inquire if she can cash in her Brilliance University educational insurance. She was told she wouldn’t get anything. Zero. Zilch. For her P87,000 initial payment, she will get a cash surrender value of P1,055 -- but only in the second year.
By any measure, this seems to me like a big swindle. Even banks, if you place a time deposit and want to get out, you pay a termination fee of just 20 percent. With Philam, the pretermination fee is 100 percent. You lose all your money. They take away your money. Just like that. "
When that mother of three was offered educational insurance, the agent explained that she will have to place money for a certain number of years and when her child reaches age 16, she will receive the following cash benefits. If something happens(death or disability) to her, she will be assured that her child will continue to receive those scheduled benefits as stated in the policy contract. And since she is not capable of working anymore, her policy will let her child have additional funding for his/her elementary and high school. Isn't that a good deal for someone who wants her 3 children assured of education?
What the mother of three instead did was to have read your article or other people's article that has no clear understanding and makes her panic like hell.
And now that you know what you did to that mother of three. The education of her children will now depend on what you will say. I expect you to clear things up for her and tell her that the Insurance Commissioner will assure her that the Policy will stand to its promises.
Do you know the story of the Boy who cried wolf? Don't be that boy, the Good Lord is looking. God bless you. God bless Philamlife.
You seem to have very good knowledge about the mess AIG got into if the figures and insinuations you wrote were to be believed completely.
Just like in the case of some Chinese products, I need to be very careful for there might be some hidden things not suitable for human consumption.
Your comparison between an insurance product and a bank product is completely mixed up and has no factual basis specially the figures you mentioned which are glaringly inaccurate.
I am a ten year banker and a treasury trader and in my very young experience in handling bank transactions, I have yet to see a client being assess of a whopping 20% pre-termination charges in his time deposit for any tenor. If that happens, I am almost certain that banks will collapse like domino's because of massive withdrawals not to mention potential legal problems for the bank.
The product "Brilliance" of Philamlife which you mentioned to be a swindle is obviously an insurance product. I happen to know the product since it is the same educational plan my best friend got for his 2 children age 4 and 1. Incidentally, I was with my best friend when it was presented to him and I fully understood how the product works. The contract guarantees a fixed amount of money to be given to my friend for the education of his children which will commence only when the two child reach the age of 16 in consideration of a certain amount of money to be paid by my friend to Philamlife for a period of five years.
Obviously if my best friend will decide to revoke the contract unilaterally by surrendering the policy sooner than the 16th birthday of his children, FOR ALL PRACTICAL PURPOSES, the insurance company is not duty bound to refund the paid amount of my friend for there is no liability yet arising from the contract in favor of my friend.
Let me give you my simple analogy. If you are bound for Cebu and you buy a one way ticket via super ferry, the shipping company has the juridical necessity to take you to Cebu provided you pay for the ticket. If few meters upon taking off from the pier you decide to jump off the ship and asks for a ticket refund, don't get mad because it is you unilaterally who revoked the contract and for ALL PRACTICAL PURPOSES, the shipping company cannot be compelled to give you a refund much less that a passenger like you in your lucid mind should not insinuate that you've been swindled.
Please be careful with your advice to your readers specially the one that involves investments...you don't know how it feels inside the dealing room.
Post a Comment